A Tale of Two Bike Shorts

When I first got into cycling (because Michael was so into it, it grew on me) I bought a pair of low-end cycling shorts from the Pearl Izumi outlet store. They worked great. They may have been low-end in price but the quality was decent.

Pearl Izumi Bike Shorts

The chamois (padding) was actually pretty good for being entry-level. These bike shorts are my favorite because the padding is good and it worked well for long rides. I biked Reach the Beach in these shorts (55 miles) and when I do long rides in training for the Portland Century I use these shorts.

The problem with Shorts #1? They are a size medium and the waist is tight and uncomfortable. Depending on how much I weigh it can dig into my skin and irritate it. (When I did Reach the Beach I was 10 pounds heavier than I am now.)

Reach the Beach

Bike Shorts #2 are a pair of Sugoishorts that were sent to me from a company last year. They are higher quality than the Pearls but the chamois doesn’t have much padding. As a result I don’t wear these shorts for long rides. They are a size Large so they don’t dig into my waist.

Recently I ordered a pair of women’s bib shorts. ¬†I was skeptical about getting bib shorts but Michael raved about them so much and he loved how comfortable his shorts were I decided to give it a try. In fact, if you missed it, he wrote a post on Why You Shouldn’t Buy Cycling Shorts.

First I have to say that the service I got from RealCylist.com was amazing. I ordered the shorts on the Friday of 4th of July weekend and received them Tuesday! I was expecting it to take at least a week, especially with the holiday.

I tried on the bib shorts and they were too small. I went off the sizing chart and it said I was a medium according to my measurements. Not so much. The return was super easy. I printed out the UPS form and dropped it off and my exchange came a few days later. So easy!

I received the size Large and it turned out they were defective–one leg was tighter than the other. I called, spoke to a human being (what a change!) and they immediately shipped out a replacement. I called on Monday night and received the replacement Wednesday! That’s what I call service! And the new pair fit like a dream! They are perfect.

Details about the Giordana Forma Red Carbon Custom Bib Shorts:

  • Aerofix waistband and bib, which consists of Ametista backed with stretchy, breathable Antigua fabric, holds the shorts in place without pressure points or digging
  • Wide Aerofix cuffs offer extra support and prevent the short from riding up
  • Low-profile Alta OmniForm chamois, Giordana’s top-of-the-line insert, provides low-bulk comfort, protection and support
  • Rear micromesh panel is treated to enhance wicking

I wish I hadn’t waited so long to try the bib shorts! What a difference in comfort they make. I’m not entirely happy with the chamois in my new bib shorts, though. After a few longer test rides I noticed that the padding wasn’t quite enough. I know there will be a way to fix that though. It’s not a total loss: I found out the superior comfort of bib shorts! I am converted!

QUESTION: What do you wear when you bike? Have you tried bib shorts?

Why You Shouldn’t Buy Cycling Shorts

Why You Shouldn’t Buy Cycling Shorts

Guest Post by Michael

Cycling shorts are the worst things ever. Everyone wears them though, right? I see people around town wearing these things everyday so how could the be bad? I mean, they’re supposed to be good…To clarify, I’m talking about cycling shorts, like these.


Cycling shorts exist to increase your performance. They allow you to ride longer distances than you’d be able to do if you wore regular shorts. They have moisture wicking padding (called a chamois) that lines up between your body and your saddle. The tight legs are designed to provide compression to your quad muscles that are supposed to provide increased circulation and blood flow. There should be some type of material that prevents the legs from riding up. These commonly feel a little bit like rubber or dried rubber cement. These shouldn’t irritate the hair on your legs or your skin but should hold them in place. But remember, cycling shorts suck.

These things suck because the waist is terribly uncomfortable. All brands are like this. There is no great brand that doesn’t do this — they’re always too tight. I could just lose a few more pounds but really, this won’t resolve the issue. Besides, there are cycling shorts that don’t suck. They’re called bib shorts and all of the pros wear them. When in doubt, look to the pros. They ride 100 miles a day so they’re going to be smart about the gear they wear.

Bib shorts are far more comfortable because they don’t have a waist band. Now, you’ll feel ridiculous when you put these on because you’ll think that everyone that sees you will laugh at you for wearing shorts with built in suspenders. Once you put on a jersey though, no one can even tell whether you’re wearing shorts or bib shorts but you’ll know because you’ll be far more comfortable than those who are wearing cycling shorts.

All brands of bib shorts are not created equally. Personally, I like Craft clothing. Craft makes triathlete clothing as well which may appeal to some readers.

There’s really only two things to look for when you buy bib shorts — the height of the waist of the shorts and the chamois quality.

Waists — Some people will prefer the lower waist and some will prefer the higher waist.

High Waist Bibs


Low Waist Bibs

The higher waist can help keep your stomach flatter and out of the way while you pedal though some people will hate the sensation of wearing a high-waisted pair of shorts. I prefer the low waist variety and could stand to use a few lbs around the midsection. The moral of the story is that you’ll really want to try these on before you buy them or if you’re shopping online, buy one of each with the intention of returning the pair you like less.

Women’s bib shorts can look quite a bit different than men’s equivalent. I cannot give you any advice on these. I can’t even figure out how you’d get some of these on your body let alone pretend to know which is the most comfortable style. I imagine it will vary by body type.

Women's Bibs

Women's Bib


If you’re buying an Italian brand like Castelli, remember to order at least one size up. I’m 5’11” and wear an XXL and that has nothing to do with my weight. I normally wear a size L t-shirt. The American brands tend to be more size-true but they are commonly inferior in quality.

Chamois quality is very important if you want to be comfortable out there. Many people don’t know this but you are not supposed to wear underwear with cycling shorts because the chamois needs to touch your skin in order to wick moisture properly. Now that you know this, you’re probably thinking that it’s worth the money to spend an extra $30 to get the good chamois.

You want your chamois to have a smooth surface to it with a series of indentations that allow the chamois to bend to your body’s shape and not bunch up. Run your fingers over it. If there’s any variance in texture, it feels like a packing foam or a slightly dried sponge, move on. They should not have any seams on them beyond what is around the edges to attach them to the shorts. If you stick with Craft and Castelli, you’ll do fine.

Here is a brief look at the different types of chamois Craft makes. These all appear to be good quality though I’ve not seen all of these in person. Note that the tri chamois is smaller and thinner. This is so it dries faster and is easier to run in than traditionally shaped chamois are.

One last note on shorts in general: Don’t buy shorts that are white in the crotch. I’ve heard stories that these can be see-through. Unless you’re in to that sort of thing…

How do I know this stuff? Well, I first bought a pair of Pearl Izumi shorts thinking they would be good. They weren’t. They sucked. Then my friend said I should get a pair of Castlli’s. The chamois was better but they still sucked. That same friend suggested I get some bib shorts. I didn’t really want to spend that much money for shorts but I begrudgingly agreed to after he insisted they were better. He was right. He was sooooo right. In fact, this is all I’ll wear anymore. Don’t make my mistakes. Buy bib shorts from the get-go and you’ll be much happier much sooner than I was.

QUESTION: Do you ride your bike with or without bike shorts?